Where to Stay in the Bahamas: A Complete Accommodation Guide

If you’ve ever dreamed of waking up to gentle ocean breezes, crystal-clear waters, and endless sunshine, the Bahamas is where those dreams become reality. With over 700 islands and cays, each offering its own charm, the hardest part isn’t deciding whether to visit; it’s figuring out where to stay. From ultra-luxury resorts on private islands to budget-friendly guesthouses near vibrant local markets, the Bahamas offers accommodations for every travel style and budget. In this guide, I’ll walk you through the different types of stays, share insider tips, and help you choose the perfect home base. Whether you’re here for romance, family fun, adventure, or relaxation, there’s a spot in the Bahamas with your name on it. How to Choose the Right Bahamas Stay for Your Travel Style Choosing the perfect place to stay in the Bahamas starts with knowing what you want out of your trip. Are you looking for the buzz of nightlife and restaurants, or do you prefer a secluded beach where the only footprints are your own? Are you a luxury traveler chasing the ultimate spa experience, or a backpacker eager to connect with locals? If you need help deciding which island suits your personality best, get the Bahamas islands overview for an in-depth comparison of all major islands. Overview of Accommodation Types Across the Bahamas With such a wide variety of islands, it’s no surprise that the Bahamas offers an equally diverse range of places to stay. From glamorous five-star resorts where every detail is taken care of, to rustic beachside cottages where you can watch the sunrise in peace, there’s a perfect fit for every type of traveler. Below, I’ve broken down the main accommodation categories, sharing what makes each unique, where you’ll find them, the price range you can expect, and who they’re best suited for, plus my personal top five recommendations for each. Luxury Resorts These properties are the epitome of indulgence — think white-glove service, world-class dining, championship golf courses, and infinity pools that seem to spill into the sea. Many are set on prime beachfront locations, offering private cabanas and butlers to anticipate your every need. Perfect for travelers seeking nothing but the finest amenities and a truly pampered escape. Top 5 Suggestions: The Ocean Club, A Four Seasons Resort (Paradise Island), Grand Isle Resort & Residences (Great Exuma), Rosewood Baha Mar (Nassau), SLS Baha Mar (Nassau), The Cove at Atlantis (Paradise Island)Location: Paradise Island, Nassau, Great Exuma, select Out IslandsBudget: $500–$1,500+ per nightSuitable for: Honeymooners, luxury travelers, special occasions Private Island Resorts For those who want complete seclusion, these resorts offer entire islands for your exclusive use or with just a few other guests. Expect personalized service, private chefs, pristine beaches, and activities tailored exactly to your preferences. This is the ultimate getaway for privacy, romance, and high-profile escapes. Top 5 Suggestions: Kamalame Cay (Andros), Fowl Cay Resort (Exumas), Musha Cay (Exumas), Over Yonder Cay (Exumas), Lighthouse Point Residences (Eleuthera)Location: Mainly Exumas, Andros, and EleutheraBudget: $3,000–$50,000 per night (often exclusive buyouts)Suitable for: Ultra-luxury travelers, celebrities, private group retreats Boutique Hotels Small in size but big on personality, boutique hotels offer a more intimate atmosphere with stylish decor, unique architecture, and personalized touches you won’t find in large resorts. Many are run by locals or families, making them ideal for travelers who want authenticity along with comfort. Top 5 Suggestions: Rock House Hotel (Harbour Island), Pineapple Fields Resort (Eleuthera), Graycliff Hotel (Nassau), Bahama Beach Club (Abaco), Coral Sands Hotel (Harbour Island)Location: Harbour Island, Eleuthera, Nassau, AbacoBudget: $250–$600 per nightSuitable for: Couples, small families, culture lovers All-Inclusive Resorts One price covers everything — accommodations, meals, drinks, and often activities like snorkeling, sailing, or nightly entertainment. These resorts make it easy to relax without constantly thinking about your budget, and they’re perfect for travelers who want convenience above all else. Top 5 Suggestions: Sandals Emerald Bay (Exuma), Viva Wyndham Fortuna Beach (Grand Bahama), Breezes Resort & Spa (Nassau), Warwick Paradise Island (Adults Only), Club Med Columbus Isle (San Salvador)Location: Nassau, Paradise Island, Exuma, Grand Bahama, San SalvadorBudget: $300–$700 per night (double occupancy)Suitable for: Couples, families, all-in-one vacation seekers Budget Hotels and Inns Affordable doesn’t mean you have to compromise on location or comfort. Many budget stays in the Bahamas are close to beaches, public transportation, and local restaurants, giving you easy access to the islands without draining your wallet. Top 5 Suggestions: El Greco Hotel (Nassau), Pelican Bay Hotel (Grand Bahama), Royal Palm Hotel (Harbour Island), Island Time Villas (Exuma), Orange Hill Beach Inn (Nassau)Location: Nassau, Grand Bahama, Exuma, Harbour IslandBudget: $100–$200 per nightSuitable for: Backpackers, solo travelers, Bahamas Budget travelers Vacation Rentals and Villas If you want privacy, extra space, and the comforts of home, vacation rentals are the way to go. Many villas come with full kitchens, private pools, and beachfront access, making them great for longer stays or group trips. Top 5 Suggestions: Airbnb Luxe Bahamas (Various Islands), Exuma Beach Rental Villas, Harbour Island Beach Houses, Nassau Oceanfront Villas, Eleuthera Family VillasLocation: All islands, most common in Exuma, Harbour Island, Nassau, EleutheraBudget: $250–$1,500 per nightSuitable for: Groups, extended families, privacy seekers Eco-Lodges & Eco-Friendly Resorts These properties combine comfort with sustainability, often running on renewable energy and offering organic dining options. Staying here means enjoying the Bahamas’ natural beauty while helping protect it. Top 5 Suggestions: Small Hope Bay Lodge (Andros), Tiamo Resort (Andros), Fernandez Bay Village (Cat Island), Andros South Lodge, Bimini Big Game Club Resort (Bimini)Location: Andros, Cat Island, BiminiBudget: $300–$800 per nightSuitable for: Eco-conscious travelers, nature lovers Bed & Breakfasts (B&Bs) Perfect for travelers who value personal touches and local hospitality. Many B&Bs serve home-cooked breakfasts and offer insider recommendations on hidden beaches or local events. Top 5 Suggestions: A Stone’s Throw Away (Nassau), La Bougainvillea (Eleuthera), Banana Bay Resort (Grand Bahama), Driftwood Beach B&B (Abaco), Tingum Village Hotel (Harbour Island)Location: Nassau, Eleuthera, Grand Bahama, Harbour Island, AbacoBudget: $150–$300 per nightSuitable for: Couples, solo travelers, cultural explorers Marinas & Yacht Clubs If you’re arriving by boat,